性闻联播

'If these walls could talk'

Photograph by Pavel Romaniko of vintage Russian car after accident
"Russian history is an accident that keeps repeating itself," photographer Pavel Romaniko says, in explaining his photo, "Untitled (Accident I)."

Asst. Teaching Prof. , whose family has roots in both Ukraine and Russia, is divided by war. 

Yet long before Russia invaded Ukraine, Romaniko, of the , was meditating on the diminishment of free artistic and political expression and the erasure of historical memory in Russia through his photographs of reconstructed, depopulated spaces.

His book, exhibit and ongoing photographic project  brings to mind the saying, 鈥淚f these walls could talk.鈥 

In Romaniko's photographs, windows in the walls look onto other walls, as in "Untitled (Empty Room III)."
In Romaniko's photographs, windows in the walls look onto other walls, as in "Untitled (Empty Room III)."

Romaniko鈥檚 walls and rooms are empty of people, except propaganda portraits and statues of authoritarian Soviet and Russian leaders. But they speak quiet volumes about history and Russian society for those who know how to read them: the glorification of former Soviet dictator Josef Stalin; the absence of art in a famous art gallery; windows that look onto more walls. 

Romaniko, who directs the new , first came to the United States from Russia as a high school exchange student and later earned his B.A. at Northwestern College, a small Baptist school in St. Paul, Minnesota. He earned his M.F.A. in imaging arts at Rochester Institute of Technology and has taught at UMass Lowell since fall 2015.

Recently, he spoke about his work and the war.

Q: All of the works in 鈥淣ostalgia鈥 are photos of intricate paper models. Why make these detailed models in paper when you could create images digitally?

A: In 鈥淎 Guide to Collective Melancholie,鈥 I restore things. I either go to a physical space or I find a photograph 鈥 mine or someone else鈥檚, significant or insignificant 鈥 and then I reconstruct it as a miniature paper model, light it and re-photograph it.

In "Untitled (Lesnaya Street)," Romaniko portrays the building where an independent journalist was assassinated in 2006.
In "Untitled (Lesnaya Street)," Romaniko portrays the building where an independent journalist was assassinated in 2006.

Paper is essential because it鈥檚 a documentation. I am constantly writing things on paper; I鈥檓 always documenting things. 

In the Soviet Union, they would say, 鈥淚f you don鈥檛 have a document, you don鈥檛 exist.鈥 My birth certificate is a piece of paper that has no actual relationship to fact, yet it鈥檚 so important. 

I was born in Kazakhstan when it was part of the USSR, but when I was 1 month old, my family moved to a small town outside Moscow where my dad鈥檚 parents lived. When my grandfather died shortly afterward, my parents wanted to rename me after him 鈥 and to get a new birth certificate with a new name on it, they had to list me as being born there.

Q: Why is your work titled 鈥淣ostalgia鈥? 

A: The title is satire. Nostalgia is dangerous because it requires no imagination.

Nostalgic thinking never implies an actual place; it implies a return to a utopian space. It employs a sense of historical forgetting, and in the present moment, it manufactures a context for that past that鈥檚 utopian or idealistic 鈥 and then seeks to project that into the future. 

An empty room with a blank canvas leaning against one wall and a single black chair against the other
Romaniko recreates the art gallery where Kazimir Malevich exhibited "Black Square" and other paintings in 1915 in "Untitled (Dobychina Bureau)."

Nostalgia always requires an audience, and any analytical inquiry into it will crumple it. But inquiry requires reflection, and people who deal in nostalgia do not want to reflect.

My art is a reflection on my own futility and impotence in knowing or understanding certain things, but not being able to do anything about them. Protesting in Russia is a deadly sport. There are all these brave people who have resisted knowingly and courageously, and I鈥檓 not one of them, so there鈥檚 always that sense of helplessness. 

Q: The only people present in your 鈥淣ostalgia鈥 photos are portraits and sculptures of Soviet and Russian leaders, from Vladimir Lenin to Vladimir Putin. What is the historical context for some of your works?

A: The book begins and ends with photos that show a car, modeled on the Soviet Lada, that has been in an accident. Russian history is an accident that keeps repeating itself. Russians haven鈥檛 dealt with their past; they haven鈥檛 explicitly acknowledged that what Stalin did in Ukraine was wrong, fundamentally wrong, against his own people. And now they鈥檙e trying to bring Stalin back as a hero of the past. 

鈥淯ntitled (Lesnaya Street)鈥 and 鈥淯ntitled (Stairwell)鈥 are recreations of the building and hallway where independent journalist Anna Politkovskaya was assassinated on Vladimir Putin鈥檚 birthday in 2006. 

"Untitled (Gallery II)" is a display of standard propaganda photos of authoritarian Soviet and Russian leaders.
"Untitled (Gallery II)" is a display of standard propaganda photos of authoritarian Soviet and Russian leaders.

In the room with four chairs facing a television set, the TV is the type on which people would have seen (former Soviet Premier Nikita) Khrushchev give Crimea to Ukraine in 1954.

鈥淯ntitled (0.10)鈥 is a reconstruction of the gallery where the artist Kazimir Malevich exhibited his famous painting 鈥淏lack Square鈥 in 1915, as part of 鈥淭he Last Futurist Exhibition of Painting 0.10.鈥 

Q: In your reconstruction, the gallery is empty, with only a single canvas turned to the wall. And your photo 鈥淯ntitled (Gallery)鈥 contains not art, but the standard propaganda photos of Soviet and Russian leaders 鈥 minus Mikhail Gorbachev and Boris Yeltsin, who oversaw the dissolution of the Soviet Union and an era of greater political and artistic openness. In your view, what is the relationship between politics and art?

A: Art is never apolitical. The act of making artwork in a totalitarian society is an act of dissent. Simply producing artwork is a form of free expression: It鈥檚 why literature is a danger to totalitarian societies, because it undermines their message. 

A vintage tv set with four wooden chairs around it sits in a room with pink wallpaper
In "Untitled (TV I)" Romaniko portrays the type of TV set on which Soviet citizens would have watched Nikita Khrushchev "give" Crimea to Ukraine in 1954.

Art exposes the mechanics of thinking of the artist himself. Visual art suggests a space in which one could say, 鈥淭hat鈥檚 an interesting way to think about this.鈥 And what a totalitarian space says is, 鈥淣o, you can鈥檛 think about this in any other way.鈥

Russia just passed a law killing internal dissent. That鈥檚 the context of my work.

Q: You have spoken out about your opposition to the invasion of Ukraine. How has it affected you?

A: Until the minute of the invasion, I and many Russians I know thought the military buildup was a bluff. I just broke down and I wept. I have a lot of friends I would see cry on the phone; they would never support the invasion, but we feel guilt even though we don鈥檛 live in Russia and there鈥檚 nothing we can do. It鈥檚 a feeling of impotence.

It鈥檚 hard to find a Russian who doesn鈥檛 have connections to Ukraine one way or another, and that鈥檚 what makes it almost impossible to grasp. On my mother鈥檚 side of the family, my great-grandparents were forcibly resettled from Ukraine to the plains of Kazakhstan under Stalin. My cousin, who I鈥檓 very close with, lived in Ukraine most of her life, but she just moved to Russia a few years ago. My uncle lived there for a good part of his life. 

The invasion really is just a war of one man, but unfortunately, everyone else is complicit by affiliation. I think that鈥檚 what a lot of Russians are feeling now: There鈥檚 a lot of shame, a lot of guilt, because they鈥檙e feeling complicit. 

I love my country, but I don鈥檛 love my nation.